Coupe Coenegracht: Limburg vs. Limburg


Introduction
Matches

Introduction

The first suggestion to hold a match between the homonymous and adjacent Belgian and Dutch provinces of Limburg appears to have originated from a Belgian sports periodical, "La Vie Sportive". The idea was adopted by Louis "Lou" Coenegracht, born in Maastricht, who had founded the Comité Provincial du Limbourg Belge in 1908 when living in Hasselt and had returned to the town of his birth in 1910, where he became (before moving to Switzerland in 1911) the president of the Limburgsche Voetbalbond, founded in 1908. He offered a prize, the "Coupe Coenegracht", which was contested twice a season, home and away. No conditions were specified on obtaining permanent ownership of the trophy, but at the occasion of the 25th meeting, Coenegracht, meanwhile living in Brussels but a regular attendant at the matches, decided to award it to Dutch Limburg, which had won 15 of the 25 matches played until then.
He immediately offered a new trophy, for which, according to the annual Voetbal Jaarboekje published by the K.N.V.B. in the late thirties, the condition to obtain permanent ownership was winning it five times. It is not clear whether this referred to winning five matches (in which case Dutch Limburg would have won it after match 33, on 15 May 1938), five successive matches (Belgian Limburg won five-in-a-row between matches 41 and 45; Dutch Limburg won seven-in-a-row between matches 55 and 61), five annual series (difficult to decide due to the interruption caused by World War II) or five successive annual series (which never happened) but eventually it was handed at the occasion of match 64, the last attended by the initiator of the matches himself, to Belgian Limburg, at the occasion of the golden jubilee of the series, apparently based on the overall count of the matches held since the first trophy had been awarded to Dutch Limburg (so matches 26 to 64), which saw a lead for the Belgians by a single goal.
Matches were played since, annually until 1967, later at irregular intervals, for a third trophy, again offered by Louis Coenegracht, but it is not clear under which conditions permanent ownership was to be obtained. Since the eighties several matches between youth selections were held under the "Coenegracht" tag.

The matches between the two Limburgs were often called "semi-interlands" in Dutch, like the regular meetings between Luxembourg and South Netherlands, East Netherlands and West Germany, and North Netherlands and North Germany.


Matches

Game    Date     Venue                             Result               

  1  14- 5-1911  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    2-2 Dutch Limburg        
  2  17- 3-1912  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      2-1 Belgian Limburg    
  3  27- 5-1912  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    1-2 Dutch Limburg      
  4   8-12-1912  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      3-0 Belgian Limburg    
  5  15- 6-1913  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    3-2 Dutch Limburg      
  6   5-10-1913  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      3-0 Belgian Limburg    
  7  16-11-1913  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    2-1 Dutch Limburg      
  8  21- 5-1925  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    3-0 Dutch Limburg      
  9   8-11-1925  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      3-1 Belgian Limburg    
 10   1- 8-1926  Treebeek         Dutch Limburg      3-2 Belgian Limburg    
 11   8- 8-1926  Tongeren         Belgian Limburg    5-0 Dutch Limburg      
 12   3- 4-1927  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      5-1 Belgian Limburg    
 13  15- 5-1927  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    2-3 Dutch Limburg      
 14  11- 3-1928  Treebeek         Dutch Limburg      3-3 Belgian Limburg    
 15  20- 5-1928  Sint-Truiden     Belgian Limburg    2-2 Dutch Limburg      
 16   1-12-1929  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    1-4 Dutch Limburg      
 17  27- 4-1930  Venlo            Dutch Limburg      4-1 Belgian Limburg    
 18  17- 5-1931  Bocholt          Belgian Limburg    4-3 Dutch Limburg      
 19  26- 7-1931  Spekholzerheide  Dutch Limburg      4-3 Belgian Limburg    
 20  24- 4-1932  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      2-0 Belgian Limburg    
 21   8- 5-1932  Borgloon         Belgian Limburg    2-4 Dutch Limburg      
 22  28- 5-1933  Heerlen          Dutch Limburg      4-1 Belgian Limburg    
 23  11- 6-1933  Genk             Belgian Limburg    4-3 Dutch Limburg      
 24  11- 3-1934  Bilsen           Belgian Limburg   6-10 Dutch Limburg      
 25  29- 4-1934  Tegelen          Dutch Limburg      5-6 Belgian Limburg    

Dutch Limburg          25  15  3  7  77- 56  33
Belgian Limburg        25   7  3 15  56- 77  17

NB: Dutch Limburg won first trophy after 25 matches; a new trophy was put on offer.

in Belgium
Belgian Limburg        13   6  2  5  37- 36  14
Dutch Limburg          13   5  2  6  36- 37  12

in the Netherlands
Dutch Limburg          12  10  1  1  41- 19  21
Belgian Limburg        12   1  1 10  19- 41   3

Game    Date     Venue                             Result               

 26  28- 4-1935  Roermond         Dutch Limburg      6-4 Belgian Limburg    
 27  12- 5-1935  Tongeren         Belgian Limburg    1-2 Dutch Limburg      
 28  30- 3-1936  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    5-4 Dutch Limburg      
 29  17- 5-1936  Lutterade        Dutch Limburg      4-3 Belgian Limburg    
 30  29- 3-1937  Lanaeken         Belgian Limburg    3-4 Dutch Limburg      
 31  18- 4-1937  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      2-4 Belgian Limburg    
 32  10- 4-1938  Tongeren         Belgian Limburg    4-1 Dutch Limburg      
 33  15- 5-1938  Brunssum         Dutch Limburg      4-1 Belgian Limburg    
 34  23- 4-1939  Tongeren         Belgian Limburg    1-2 Dutch Limburg      
 35  18- 5-1939  Heer             Dutch Limburg      3-2 Belgian Limburg    
 36  21- 4-1940  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    5-1 Dutch Limburg      
  -  26- 5-1940  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      n/p Belgian Limburg    
 37  30- 6-1946  Sint-Truiden     Belgian Limburg    8-4 Dutch Limburg      
  -  15- 8-1946                     cancelled
 38  14- 6-1947  Sittard          Dutch Limburg      1-3 Belgian Limburg    
 39  17- 8-1947  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    7-7 Dutch Limburg      
 40  24- 8-1947  Kerkrade         Dutch Limburg      7-1 Belgian Limburg    
 41  18- 4-1948  Tongeren         Belgian Limburg    4-1 Dutch Limburg      
 42  30- 5-1948  Roermond         Dutch Limburg      2-3 Belgian Limburg    
 43  24- 4-1949  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      3-7 Belgian Limburg    
 44  22- 5-1949  Beringen         Belgian Limburg    3-2 Dutch Limburg      
 45   1- 5-1950  Tongeren         Belgian Limburg    3-1 Dutch Limburg      
 46  18- 5-1950  Venlo            Dutch Limburg      4-1 Belgian Limburg    
 47  26- 3-1951  Eisden           Belgian Limburg    4-2 Dutch Limburg      
 48  16- 6-1951  Sittard          Dutch Limburg      2-3 Belgian Limburg    
 49   6- 4-1952  Genk             Belgian Limburg    1-0 Dutch Limburg      
 50  22- 5-1952  Brunssum         Dutch Limburg      3-3 Belgian Limburg    
 51  19- 4-1953  Tongeren         Belgian Limburg    2-2 Dutch Limburg      
 52  27- 6-1953  Spekholzerheide  Dutch Limburg      4-3 Belgian Limburg    
 53   4- 4-1954  Waterschei       Belgian Limburg    2-1 Dutch Limburg      
 54   7- 6-1954  Heerlen          Dutch Limburg      1-3 Belgian Limburg    
 55   3- 7-1955  Geleen           Dutch Limburg      4-1 Belgian Limburg    
 56  20- 9-1955  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    0-3 Dutch Limburg      
 57  17- 6-1956  Geleen           Dutch Limburg      3-1 Belgian Limburg    
 58  25- 9-1956  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    4-5 Dutch Limburg      
 59  10- 6-1957  Geleen           Dutch Limburg      2-1 Belgian Limburg    
 60   4-12-1957  Waterschei       Belgian Limburg    3-4 Dutch Limburg      
 61   6- 6-1959  Sittard          Dutch Limburg      3-0 Belgian Limburg    
 62  24- 2-1960  Sint-Truiden     Belgian Limburg    1-1 Dutch Limburg      
 -      11-1960  Geleen             cancelled
 63  12- 4-1961  Geleen           Dutch Limburg      0-1 Belgian Limburg    
 64  19- 9-1961  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    0-0 Dutch Limburg      

NB: match number 64 was the last attended by founder Louis "Lou" Coenegracht;
    it also marked the 50-year existence of the event, at which occasion the
    second trophy was at stake, won by Belgian Limburg.

Dutch Limburg          64  32  8 24 182-162  72
Belgian Limburg        64  24  8 32 162-182  56

in Belgium
Belgian Limburg        33  16  6 11  98- 83  38
Dutch Limburg          33  11  6 16  83- 98  28

in the Netherlands
Dutch Limburg          31  21  2  8  99- 64  44
Belgian Limburg        31   8  2 21  64- 99  18


matches for second trophy (1935-1961):
Belgian Limburg        39  17  5 17 106-105  39
Dutch Limburg          39  17  5 17 105-106  39

Game    Date     Venue                             Result               

  -   2- 3-1963  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      n/p Belgian Limburg    
 65  19-10-1963  Sittard          Dutch Limburg      4-2 Belgian Limburg    
 66  21- 3-1964  Waterschei       Belgian Limburg    4-3 Dutch Limburg      
 67  15- 5-1965  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      2-4 Belgian Limburg    
 68  16- 4-1966  Hasselt          Belgian Limburg    1-5 Dutch Limburg      
 69  15- 4-1967  Sittard          Dutch Limburg      9-1 Belgian Limburg    
NB: the trophy was not contested between 1968 and 1971; since 1972 the
    match featured amateur selections.
 70  13- 5-1972  Tongeren         Belgian Limburg    0-0 Dutch Limburg      
 71  30- 4-1973  Nieuwenhagen     Dutch Limburg      0-3 Belgian Limburg    
 72? 30- 4-1975  Brunssum         Dutch Limburg      1-2 Belgian Limburg   
 75?  5- 6-1977  Montfort         Dutch Limburg      1-2 Belgian Limburg   
NB: it is not known whether matches were held in 1974 and 1976, though the
    logic (alternating hosts) of the series suggests matches were played
    in Belgium in both years; the numbering of the matches was subject to
    various inconsistencies since World War II, but the match in 1973 was
    reported as the 71st, that in 1975 as the 72nd (probably incorrectly)
    and that in 1977 as the 75th.

Dutch Limburg          73  35  9 29 207-181  79
Belgian Limburg        73  29  9 35 181-207  67

in Belgium
Belgian Limburg        36  17  7 12 103- 91  41
Dutch Limburg          36  12  7 17  91-103  31

in the Netherlands
Dutch Limburg          37  23  2 12 116- 78  48
Belgian Limburg        37  12  2 23  78-116  26

NB: at the occasion of the 150th anniversary of the split of the province
    Limburg (created in 1815) in 1839, upon the recognition of Belgium's
    independence by the Netherlands, a one-off match between professional
    representative sides was played with the Coenegracht Trofee at stake;
    the selection of the hosts consisted of players from Fortuna Sittard,
    MVV, Roda JC and VVV, while that of the visitors included players from
    Lommelse SK, Patro Eisden, RC Genk, Sint-Truidense VV and SK Tongeren;
    all these clubs played at the first or second national level.

  -  24-10-1989  Maastricht       Dutch Limburg      3-0 Belgian Limburg    


About this document

Prepared and maintained by Karel Stokkermans for the Rec.Sport.Soccer Statistics Foundation

Author: Karel Stokkermans
Last updated: 29 Sep 2024

(C) Copyright Karel Stokkermans and RSSSF 2024
You are free to copy this document in whole or part provided that proper acknowledgement is given to the author. All rights reserved.